This hot new restaurant is the place to be from what I hear. Just opened by Hugh Acheson of Athens fame, Kristen and I decided to go spend an evening at the bar. (Alison had a dinner scheduled with Trenton at the same place.) Before I go into the drinks, I will say a couple of things about the restaurant/food. It is obvious that the southern farm to table movement is alive and well in Atlanta. The “let’s use regional produce” for our meals is wonderful and quite frankly should have been started years ago. But I digress.
Empire State South (at this point) has got nothing new. In fact, other restaurants (like Wisteria for instance) just rock it so much more in taste. I will be burned at the stake for those sentences above and maybe Kristen and I just did not get some of the best menu items. ( The scallops for example were chewy and had no flavor until I put a crap ton of ground pepper on them.) Although, I will say the collard greens were the best I have ever had in a restaurant. Either way, we weren’t chomping at the bit to come back and neither were our other peeps who were there at a separate table.
Okay, enough of the food. This is about the DRINK. We ordered a few to taste (we did not actually drink all of them) but we will rate two of them: the Brown Derby and the A Martinez.
Don’t forget our ratings scale is between 1 and 5 Olives. One Olive = waste of my blogging time; 5 Olives = oh my goodness/yummmmmm
Trenton is reviewing the Brown Derby which consists of Bulleit Bourbon, fresh grapefruit, lemon, chamomile, and thyme honey. Doesn’t Trenton look dapper in this photo? His review is below:
“Presentation: 4 olives – a fun presentation of a new twist on a traditional “suh-than” bourbon drink. With a great southern name like “Brown Derby,” you almost felt bad picking up this mint leaf laden drink while not wearing seersucker and watching a sunset on Sea Island.
Creativity: 4 olives – I questioned the ability to put fresh grapefruit in a bourbon drink and retain authenticity, but this drink balanced the tight rope between edgy and authentic.
Taste: 3 olives – The “Thyme Honey Simple” won the taste battle and provide a pleasant but not overpowering sweetness. At the end of the day, the “Brown Derby” was a little too fruity for a bourbon drink, and not one you would recommend to your actual cigar loving buddies at a “derby,” but certainly enough fun for a carpetbagger to enjoy.
Overall: I give it a 4 olive overall rating!”
Kristen, as you can tell, did not like the A Martinez. It was wayyy too orange bittery. It truly tasted like bitter orange peel. The A Martinez consists of Leopold’s Gin, Luxardo Marachino Liqour, Dolin Dry Vermouth, and orange bitters.
Presentation: 2.5 olives – Served up, the drink has a nice hue to it and came with an orange peel (that was not needed because it already tasted too much like orange peel.
Creativity: 3 olives -It sounds pretty creative, doesn’t it?
Taste: 1.5 olives. We won’t give it only one olive – but it came close. We have had worse, but this just came across as too bitter (as I have said before.)
Overall: 2 olives – I’d not get it again or recommend it. Sorry!
We certainly will be back to Empire State South. And there is not doubt the restaurant will be fine even after my critical review.




















